Skip to content
PirepAeroGuidelines

Community guidelines

The short version: the pilot writes what they saw, says when they saw it, and leaves the operational information to the AIP.

Practical knowledge only

PirepAero exists for the things an official publication will never print: whether the fuel pump works at weekends, how long the walk to the terminal is, whether the club will lend the pilot a car, what the landing fee actually came to. Colour, texture, practical detail.

It does not exist for anything a pilot would use in the air, or in the last hour before a flight. That line is not a matter of taste — it is enforced by the software, and crossing it gets the submission refused before a human ever sees it.

The test

If getting it wrong could change how a flight is flown, it is operational and it does not belong here. If getting it wrong means a worse lunch, it belongs here.

The ten content rules

Every submission is checked against these before it is saved. Seven refuse the text outright and name the rule it hit; three hold it for a human to look at.

  1. RULE-01Radio frequenciesRefused automatically

    Never, in any field, in any form — not in a comment, not as "it was 122.8 when I was there". Frequencies change by NOTAM, and a wrong one on a busy day is a real hazard. The database physically cannot hold one. Link to the AIP entry instead.

  2. RULE-02Weather minima, ceilings, RVRRefused automatically

    Operational values with legal weight. They come from the AIP and from the forecast, not from what somebody remembers.

  3. RULE-03Instrument proceduresRefused automatically

    Approaches, holds, minima, missed approach — the plates are the authority, and there is no useful community version of them.

  4. RULE-04Reproduced chartsRefused automatically

    AIP and VAC charts are copyrighted. Link to the official source; never upload a scan, a photo of a screen, or a redrawn copy.

  5. RULE-05Temporary informationRefused automatically

    Works, a taxiway closed this month, a crane, a temporary restriction. That is what NOTAMs are for. PirepAero has no way to expire it in time, so it does not carry it at all.

  6. RULE-06Prescriptive circuit altitudesHeld for review

    "The circuit is usually flown over the sea to keep the noise off the village" is local knowledge. "Join at 1200 ft" is a procedure. The second kind is held for a human, and usually comes back rewritten as the first.

  7. RULE-07Runway state and obstaclesHeld for review

    Soft ground after rain, a bump halfway down, a fence that grew. Real and useful, and also the sort of thing that changes without warning — held for review so it can be phrased as a dated observation rather than a condition to plan against.

  8. RULE-08Personal contact detailsRefused automatically

    Institutional contacts only: the aero club's published office number, the handling agent's public email. Never someone's mobile, never a name or a registration attached to a story, never identifiable faces without consent.

  9. RULE-09Missing or future visit dateRefused automatically

    Every report is anchored to the day the pilot was there, and that day cannot be in the future. The date is what makes a fact ageable, and ageing is the whole mechanism.

  10. RULE-10Performance adviceHeld for review

    Take-off distances, weight and balance, technique for a short strip. The POH or AFM is the authority for the aircraft, and somebody else's experience does not substitute for it. Held for review.

No cost sharing

The pilot may use PirepAero to find people to fly with. Trips, fly-ins, an empty right seat, someone to share the day with — all fine.

The pilot may not offer, seek, advertise or arrange any payment or contribution for a flight. Not a share of the fuel, not the landing fee, not "just help with the costs". This is not a verdict on cost-shared flying in general; it is that PirepAero does not host the arranging of it, in any wording. Posts that do are removed.

Photos

The pilot uploads only photos they took themselves. Not from the aerodrome's website, not from a social media group, not from a search engine — even where there is no visible copyright notice.

No identifiable people without their consent, no registrations used to point at someone, and no charts (see RULE-04). Embedded metadata, including GPS coordinates, is stripped from every upload automatically, so the pilot's home base does not travel with the file.

Uploading a photo means it stays visible on PirepAero as part of that aerodrome's record. The terms describe what that licence covers.

How to disagree

Correcting someone is the mechanism here, not an insult. If a fact is wrong, the pilot corrects it with their own visit date; the page shows both values and lets the next visitor settle it. That is the system working, not failing.

What is not welcome: personal attacks, harassment, pile-ons, advertising, and the same complaint posted in five threads. Moderators can remove content and suspend accounts, and every such decision requires a written reason that the author can read and appeal.

What happens when a rule is broken

An automatic refusal happens at submission and names the rule, so the pilot can rephrase and try again. A flagged item waits for a moderator, who publishes it, rewrites it, or refuses it with a reason.

Repeated breaches cost reputation, and reputation is what unlocks publishing without review. Persistent abuse ends the account. Anything removed can be appealed, anyone can report content through the report page, and the decision — with its reason — ends up in the public transparency record.